All Catholic
- Track: Ella Jackson, Priscilla Schloff, Sophia Page
- Soccer: Zoë Abraham
- Tennis: Lauren Earnhardt, Ella Baron
- Golf: Daniel Megala
- Baseball: Nolan Locey
All League
- Track: David Schneider, Simon Engle, Lila Wolcott, Helene Farrell
- Soccer: Susan Nedwick, Allison Schmitt
- Tennis: Lilliana Tocco, Hannah Megala
- Golf: Dominic Walker
- Baseball: Edward Werner
All Academic
- Golf: Dominic Walker
- Baseball: Garrett Iwanski
